The tankard was very nice, and the inscribed name and map were very good. There was a bit of tarnish in the seams of the cup which I had to clean as well as 2 scratches inside the cup. It looked as though whoever cleaned and packed it had a ring on. No big deal but useful information for you for the future. Also, on the ordering page, when I selected the picture of Scotland the word "Scotland" was under the drawing. One would naturally assume this label would be there identifying the engraving. The first person who looked at it said "nice, but what's this" He obviously isn't as familiar with the map of Scotland as I am. Lastly, nowhere does the piece indicate that it's 100% Pewter which would be a nice touch. I think that with a few small changes you would have an excellent product, But that's just my opinion.