The feedback for my script was great on character and structure. It was also turned around in excellent time. My only critique was that it contained a couple of errors when referencing back to the text: but given that it was turned around in very short time I can't really blame them for that. The feedback did make me realise that my project would never go anywhere, and I agree that perhaps this is not the best service for those of us at the bottom of the food chain. I felt a bit disheartened that there was a whole could-be-selected-for development angle, tantalisingly, but that I didn't come up to scratch for - I didn't really know what to do to fix the problems based on the feedback - so I did feel that the project was hopeless. That said, I felt that they were trying to pigeonhole-hole a cross-genre idea into some tired old formulae... but perhaps that's sour grapes. I came away with the impression that the person writing the report was selecting from a list of stock responses rather than responding to the script, and I felt bad for having made them read it, but at least it stopped me from wasting another 9 months writing it! So in conclusion I'm glad that they were completely honest and didn't get my hopes up to get me to pay for further feedback or anything like that. If you really want the truth, ask Industrial Scripts.