I used both SwingTrader as well as IBD Digital. SwingTrader was horrendous, less than 10 recommendations a month and well over 50% were losers - I could do that myself and not pay for an additional "service". IBD Digital wasn't much better - I signed up to receive a concise informative daily newsletter on important market news. Instead, I received countless marketing emails and the actual "IBD Digital" emails conveyed very little important information and made you click links to read further into articles. Again, I wanted a CONCISE daily email on important market news: I don't want to click links, I don't want to read extensive articles, give me the meat and potatoes so I can hit the trading block. Robinhood offers "Robinhood Snacks" FOR FREE which is essentially what IBD Digital claims to be except it actually delivers. Before I began actively trading I had read and been told by many IBD was the gold standard but my experience has been anything but. Do better.