I have held back on giving a review as I wanted to test them out. I have just used them solidly for a harvest season at an English winery so they have been subjected to muddy vineyards and a wet and busy winery. They have been very impressive, especially when I've had them on for 12 hours plus. Yes ideally I should have a reinforced saftey toe but I went for comfort and durability and I think I got those in spades! Hopefully will last a few years. The Michelin tyre style sole really doesn't like mud sticking to it! Have to say the customer service on the phone when I had a few questions was completely first class. 5 star review from me....