2 out of 5 only because I got the items very quickly. I'm glad I decided to try this lipstick when it was buy one get one free. I would have been so disappointed had I paid full price. This lipstick is so thick and dry. When I pressed my lips together, a layer of skin came off. Now, I regularly sugar scrub my lips and constantly have them moisturized. This lipstick doesn't apply evenly and no matter how hard I tried, it looked like a toddler colored in my lips. Completely unacceptable for $19 each! And glitter? The pictures you show have beautiful sparkling glitter. The actual lipstick does have glitter, but it's dull and barely noticeable even in direct sunlight. I am highly disappointed and you should be ashamed of yourselves for charging so much for such a horrible product. I purchased 4 and tried 3 of them. All 3 had the same result. Horrifically, I tried the first one on when I wasn't home and since it stains, I was stuck with that mess on all day until I was able to get home where my remover was.