I am obsessed with this eyeliner!! It’s a absolutely the best eyeliner I have ever used I first heard about it from an Ipsy bag several-several months ago I used it and fell it love the liner is not to thin or thick so it makes applying it very easy and the black color is amazing and it last along time there’s so much in that one container and it doesn’t smudge so I set out to purchase online the color of the tube-container is now a rose gold that makes it look so sophisticated I would definitely recommend you will be completely satisfied and will never go back to your old liquid eyeliner