My experience has been good. The quictent does really well in moderate temp zones but loses heat quickly near freezing. I use a second tarp when expecting frigid temps. It’s most important to anchor with screw anchors and fasten them to the frame with rope included with the screw anchors .I use Ashman Black Ground Anchors from Amazon. They are extremely strong and compliment the stay power of the Quictent. I have two of these and use cinder blocks to help weigh down the ends to prevent wind inflation and pulling. Mine have survived 60 mph winds and many storms. I also recommend doing a criss cross pattern of ashman anchors and rope on outside during severe weather. I don’t have photos on phone to upload but maybe later I can share.