We are sorry you are unhappy with our lip oil. It's true, they are tinted lip oils and they are not very dark, this is why we use the word "tint" with the color. All three of the lip oils are designed to work with all skin tones. Here is the link to help show you what they might look like on your skin tone: https://brushonblock.com/products/protective-lip-oil-trio
“This oil is amazing! I have extremely dry lips and need to keep sunscreen on them. Most sunscreens taste awful and dry out lips. But this lip oil has no bad taste and works wonders. It also has the added benefit of a tint. Love this product!”