Hi Kenneth,
We are so sorry to hear that you aren't happy with our Herbal Horse Spray. We do want to assure you that we haven't changed our formula. Several years ago we made the decision to exclude cedarwood oil to ensure that we were making the safest and most effective product that we could, but otherwise it remains the same! We will also strive to offer sales periodically throughout the summer to give everyone a chance to stock up at a discount when supplies allow. We hope this helps and you and your horse have a safe and wonderful summer <3