“I rate this one as good only because it smells. The stitch work of the purse is great. Though I ordered the white one and it came covered in black marks on the inside. I haven't tried to clean them yet only because the smell from the bag is unbearable and even just touching it briefly to move it makes your hands smell. I've been trying to air it out for a week now but it's still very potent. apparently "PU leather" was a warning. My only other complaint is that the photos all make the crescent look like it's metal when its more of a rubber and stitched on.”