Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 189 Reviews
A much loved treat for birthdays here
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
Hi Linda, Thanks for the 5/5! We're glad Smith Island Cake is a much loved treat for birthdays. Kind regards, Team Mackenzie Limited
Posted 1 day ago
it was good
Helpful Report
Posted 1 month ago
As always, the cakes are delicious. The recipients raved about how wonderful the gift was and a hit with everyone in the organization. Thank you, Smith Island Cake, for making this event possible.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 months ago
The cake was very dry, the frosting was way to rich tasting, I didn't like the "crumbs" around the side of the cake. This cake has changed and not for the better. Very disappointed.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 3 months ago
Hi Kimberly, thanks for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry the cake didn’t meet expectations and that you found it dry, the frosting too rich, and the side crumbs not to your liking. We’ll pass this to our culinary team to review the recipe and presentation. Kind regards, Team Smith Island Cakes
Posted 3 months ago
Author didn't leave any comments.
2 Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
Wonderful. Delicious.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 5 months ago
Author didn't leave any comments.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 5 months ago
We’re sorry this item fell short and appreciate your feedback. We would love to hear how this product could receive a 5-star rating.
Posted 4 months ago
Cake was very dry! I have ordered this cake at least 4 times before, however, this time it didn't work out for me and my guest!!
2 Helpful Report
Posted 7 months ago
We’re sorry to hear that the Smith Island Cake didn’t meet your expectations, but was previously a hit! Your feedback has been shared with our product team. Thank you for taking the time to leave a review.
Posted 7 months ago