Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 175 Reviews
I ordered this cake as a Thanksgiving gift. According to the recipients, it arrived on time and in good shape and was so delicious that two adults and two small children consumed it in a week!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 day ago
A very Big thank you for an absolutely delicious cake. It was moist, rich, perfectly balanced not to sweet with incredible flavor.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 days ago
Excellent dessert anytime of the year … something different and delicious for the holidays!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 days ago
Absolutely fabulous cake! Was a hit for my dessert! Will buy again for Christmas and New Year! Moist and not too sweet! More like a European type cake!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
Excellent presentation. Cake was flavorful and very sturdy. Frosting was flavorful and plentiful and a bit grainy, as if granulated sugar were included. Packaging was over-the-top and would account for a significant portion of the cost; nothing was going to disturb that cake!
Helpful Report
Posted 2 months ago
Hi Nancy, Thank you for your thoughtful review! We’re thrilled to hear you appreciated the presentation and found the cake flavorful and sturdy. We appreciate your feedback regarding the frosting and packaging. We look forward to serving you again soon, Team Mackenzie Ltd.
Posted 2 months ago
Too sweet and dense
Helpful Report
Posted 2 months ago
Hi Manuela, Thank you for your feedback on the Smith Island Cake! We’re sorry to hear that you found it too sweet and dense for your liking. We appreciate your input as it helps us improve our offerings. We hope you give us another try in the future! Team Mackenzie Ltd.
Posted 2 months ago
Cake was too dry. Chocolate frosting was also flakey.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 6 months ago
My favorite
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
Wow! We spotted your 5-star review and wanted to say thank you. Your review and satisfaction mean the world to us!
Posted 9 months ago