Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 255 Reviews
Disappointed in the quality and taste. The cake was so dry it was hard to swallow . I thought it would be a stellar dessert, especially for the price, but at best average grocery store quality.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Great
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
The cake was wonderful and enjoyed by all. Pricey; and shipping very expensive. Not something we'll do frequently!
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Too expensive, delicious cake!!!
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
The first cake was damaged in shipment. The replacement cake arrived in good shape and arrived in the nick of time. The cake is our favorite.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
I use to stop at the Citgo gas station in Coinjock, NC to buy this cake on my way to the Outer Banks!
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Such a gorgeous cake for the holidays. And then we served it to rave reviews. Everyone commented on the rich flavor, smooth and moist. This may need to become a tradition.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
The cake was very beautiful as pictured in the catalogue. The icing was tasty but gritty.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago