Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 161 Reviews
The delivered cake was dry not moist. It was disappointing as I have had the cake before and this was not good.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
I've ordered this cake for the past three years they are delicious and always impress! You won't be sorry!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Ordered this years ago and the cake was very dry. Decided to try again for Thanksgiving this year. Everyone LOVED it! Plan on ordering another for Christmas. Best icing ever!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
I buy this cake 1 or 2 times a year and over the course of several days I eat the whole thing, a slice at a time, by myself. It keeps perfectly in a Tupperware Cake Taker and the last bite is as moist and good as the first. It's my little secret sin and I refuse to feel guilty about it!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
My family thought the cake was too dry. I won't be ordering another one.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
I loved it
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Arrived on time. Was moist and delicious! Will certainly order it again.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Jane_Stewart
Verified Reviewer
Great cake shipped perfectly. Will defintely order more items thru Mackenzie
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago