Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 171 Reviews
LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
I watched the segment on 60 minutes regarding Smith Island. During the segment they mentioned the Smith Island cake. Interested I ordered it. That being said the frosting was very good, the layers of the cake I thought seemed a little stale. The cake came well packaged and easy to defrost and serve.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
The cake was hard and dry with very little favor. It was as if it as a month old.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
Ev. year we look forward to this cake, but this year it was bit dry......J
Helpful Report
Posted 10 months ago
Visited Smith Island.. first tasted it there
Helpful Report
Posted 10 months ago
This was a standard chocolate cake that I can get in the neighborhood. The Smith Island cake is a traditional multi layer cake that is like no other. I have been buying them every year from McKenzie and have loved them, but apparently they are now being sourced elsewhere. End to another great tradition I suppose.....
1 Helpful Report
Posted 10 months ago
I sent my cake-loving brother this cake for his 70th Birthday. He gave it rave reviews, which of course, is what everyone loves to hear when sending something out of state to a loved-one. Not only will I recommend this cake, there is also a high likelihood I will be making this purchase again myself! This cake does not disappoint.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 11 months ago
Recipient loved the cake and packing for delivery.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago