Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 161 Reviews
Sent as a birthday gift all the way to Oregon, the cake was the hit of the family birthday celebration. Enough was left for my sister to treat several of her friends at the Senior Citizen Residence the next day. Thanks Mackenzie Ltd. for making this birthday special.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 months ago
Absolutely delicious! A big hit for a birthday
Helpful Report
Posted 6 months ago
This cake is virtually as good as the one my Southern mother made by hand, literally mixing it with her bare hands!
1 Helpful Report
Posted 6 months ago
Beautiful cake appeals to every taste and age. It’s our family favorite for birthdays and special celebrations.
Helpful Report
Posted 6 months ago
The best chocolate cake ever!
Helpful Report
Posted 6 months ago
This cake was the hit of the party! Beautiful 9-layers of absolute deliciousness.
Helpful Report
Posted 7 months ago
I could not taste the flavor of the cake. It was my birthday cake so disappointed
Helpful Report
Posted 7 months ago
I have ordered this cake before and loved it which is why I reordered. However, I was very disappointed this time. The frosting was very gritty and was too sweet. Clearly the sugar/chocolate mixture wasn’t heated to right temperature. We actually threw it out after each having a piece.
Helpful Report
Posted 8 months ago