Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 255 Reviews
Tiny thin delicious layers and chocolate icing like my southern aunts used to make!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
This cake reminds me of my grandmother's chocolate cake recipe that she so lovingly made for us at Christmas time. Hands down a real favorite.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
I've had terrific desserts from Mackenzie, but I found the Smith Island cake a bit dry. Ice cream with it didn't help it much. Delicious flavor though.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Delicious
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The cake was worth every penny and every calorie. I will definitely order again!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The Original Smith Island Cake was moist, delicious with a perfect chocolate icing to cake ratio. Everyone in our family enjoyed this cake. I felt good serving it to my family because of the quality and safe ingredients, which is paramount to me. It arrived completely frozen, on time and in perfect condition. Thank you for offering such exemplary quality products.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
3/4 of the cake was very dry. Flavor was just ok.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Good, but dry.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago