Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 255 Reviews
Delightful cake! Reminds me of Boston Cream Pie , yet without the custard filling. A new go to dessert!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
and everyone was wowed by the cake's sensational appearance. Makes a terrific family gift!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Everyone loved this cake, and couldn't wait to have another piece! Beautiful as well as moist with an incredible icing. Getting another, soon, to celebrate one of our friend's upcoming birthday.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Second year ordering this cake and it still lives up to all expectations we had for this year. Likely it will now become a Christmas tradition.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Was disappointed. Cake was fine, moist and good. However, the chocolate frosting wasn’t that good and was very grainy like the sugar wasn’t dissolved. We were all disappointed.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
I am a Maryland native but never had the pleasure of tasting one of your cakes. My last visit found me in Chrisfield eating a slice. It was the most delicious dance in my mouth. I decided to buy them for relatives this Christmas and they are now hooked. We will have to buy them every year.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Received in good condition and it is very delicious! Could not be better
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
I have ordered this cake for the holidays for 4 consecutive years. It is so moist and the chocolate is smooth. Simply marvelous! Everyone loves this dessert.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago