Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 171 Reviews
I have ordered this cake before and loved it which is why I reordered. However, I was very disappointed this time. The frosting was very gritty and was too sweet. Clearly the sugar/chocolate mixture wasn’t heated to right temperature. We actually threw it out after each having a piece.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
We ordered this for my mother-in-law's birthday because it's one of her favorites. The shipping was fast and the product arrived still very cold. The cake was delicious! We are ordering the pineapple upside down mini cakes for my father-in-law's birthday and I can't wait to try them.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Big disappointment for a Birthday. Cake was stale.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Heavenly - reminds us of the old days where everything was made by hand. Kudos for a wonderful cake making us smile!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Thank you for that kind review. This is one of our favorites and we are glad you enjoyed it.
Posted 1 year ago
Delicius for a special desert
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Really amazing !!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
dissapointed, was dry and not fresh
1 Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
This cake after thawing was on the dry side. The chocolate was very good tasting though.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago