Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 171 Reviews
First time ordering for Christmas which was a nice break from cooking. Cake arrived intact and looked delicious. Icing roasted great, but the cake was a little dry. We ordered the Snowflake cake as well which was delicious.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Everyone loved it! Follow the instructions and it thawed very nicely.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
My family loved this cake for Christmas! Since we didn’t finish it all, we thought it would dry out, but it just got better!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Great cake!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Wanted to try this cake for so long. It was terrible. The cake was very dry and the frosting was grainy. Can’t believe I paid this much for a disappointment. Absolutely not worth it. Would have been better off with an Easy Bake Oven.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
The family to which I had a Smith Island Cake sent was familiar with that type of chocolate layered cake and considers it a "Fan Favorite". That family consists of two teenagers and two adults.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
This cake is not worth the money, don't purchase this as a gift you and then recipient will be disappointed
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Cakes were extremely unattractive and didn’t taste good either.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago