Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Key Lime Pie Reviews

4.4 Rating 95 Reviews
This Key Lime Pie is fantastic. Creamy and rich with classic key lime flavor. The pie arrives frozen in an aluminum pan. I put it directly into our refrigerator and let it thaw overnight. My family loved it! It served our family of 4, with generous servings, for about 5 days. I would order again for special occasions. It is delicious.
1 Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
This was one of the best Key Lime Pies I have ever had. It was a perfect consistency of sweet and tart. I plan on ordering again.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
My niece in Vermont, and her family, reported how much they enjoyed the Keylime pie. It’s the first time I’ve ever ordered from your company. You delivered ahead of the schedule that you had given me for delivery. It was perfect. Thank you! Mardie Shonter
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
this key lime pie is really yummy, albeit rather expensive at $49.95(in fairness, it is quite large, 9" diam). It tastes quite lime-y, isn't too sweet, and the crust is nice and thick (but not too thick). It is as good as any key lime pie I've ever eaten.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
I spent 15 years in south Florida where Key Lime Pie is King. This pie is good, but not great. The taste of condensed milk comes through. You don't need condensed milk to make Key Lime Pie....but my guests did gobble it up.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Way too sweet! Missing the tartness of true key lime pie.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
It was a gift, but they say it was excellent
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Overall a very good pie. Perhaps, a bit too sweet and sugary for my taste.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago