“Not had these long so can't give a comprehensive review and not worn them in really wet conditions so can't speak to true waterproof qualities but they have survived a couple of walks in wet grass and kept me dry. Stiff leather so they will take some time to wear in to true comfy status. The biggest thing against them and the reason a star is knocked off is the they are narrow - I got size 9 which all my other boots are but these are squeezing the little toe on my right foot and means for the minute these are relegated to short walks only until they can loosen up a bit.”