First time buyer...B&BW has always been my go-to for 3-wicks but decided to give this company a try. Bought 4 different scents: Carnival cake: Expected that terrific funnel cake smell...this is a FAIL. Smelled like a dull, burned vanilla that wasn't pleasant at all. Or really, just MEH. Marshmallow: TERRIFIC! Soft, sugary scent. Reminded me of cookies baking in the oven combined with clean, fresh linen. Odd combination I know, but it hit!! It was a combination of clean home + bakery all in one. French Toast: {Sigh}...another fail for me. A slight scent of French toast at the very beginning and thennn....nothing like French toast. What a bummer because lets face it, who doesn't love the smell of French toast in the mornings?? Butter cookie: I'm not sure it really hits the mark as a true butter cookie but it was close. I wasn't entirely disappointed with this one BUT THEN---- I burned this one along with Marshmallow at the same time and what a marriage of scents! The two burning together really did it as far as scents. Bottom line...I will give this company another try with some other scents but at this point with the holidays coming up will definitely stick with B&BW which are tried and true. I think Goose Creek can be a competitor, but not, quite, YET.