I have two little girls ages 3 and 2 who are physically totally opposite. One has a long narrow foot, and the other a wide short one. These shoes work great for each of them and the soles last through all the ground toddlers cover! My only advice would be to not buy sale items if you have not had your child wear a certain style before. The astrids and the mary janes/petals fit very differently. And so far I have purchased multiple summer and fall styles, and they EACH fit very differently. It makes it tough on returns and exchanges when you have no idea what that style will fit like. Their customer service is fantastic but they remain firm on their return/exchange policy no matter what so be warned. Great shoes, high prices but great quality. If you can afford these then you'll love them! Wish their prices were lower, kids feet grow so quickly sometimes $50+ for shoes is hard to swallow for littles.