So I'm going to be generous and give five stars as I think the quality of the food deserves it. We migrated our raw dog food to Poppy's Picnic on account of its high rating on All About Dog Food. Before moving we were using Bella & Duke, and while I'm sure the quality is high, it always had an unappetising smell like gone off spinach leaves. Our pup didn't seem to love it. She seems more keen on her new food, but I will say that I was lured by the fact that the marketing promised compostable trays when we've been sent plastic and I'm disappointed by that as it was a key reason for moving food (and swallowing the increased expense). I've contacted support and got an immediate reply that they are looking for a new supplier of compostable boxes. Really hope it gets sorted soon or I'll look around for a plastic free brand.